Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jonathan Ray's avatar

By law, all journals should have to accept all papers for publication before seeing the results, and publish at least 50% replications. Academic career points should be (citations of replicated studies)- 2x(citations of studies that failed replication)

Expand full comment
Grundvilk's avatar

I suspect at least part of the noisy science problem with psychology is the same as that encountered with trying to herd cats, or trying to reason with a tired three year-old; i.e., the subject matter being examined squirms. And, on top of that, the researcher or researchers involved also do their own squirming. Not so much a problem with the natural sciences because at least the subject matter being observed exhibits relatively stable characteristics. One less degree of freedom with the natural sciences.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts