Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Godfree Roberts's avatar

A word of warning about Frank Dikötter, the author of 'China After Mao: The Rise of a Superpower', by Chinese historian Dongping Han: "I have some dealings with this guy. Many years ago, someone in Malaysia wrote to me about his book, using the 1947 Life Magazine Photos as his front page cover and claiming that he has evidence to prove that Chairman Mao wanted to starve half of the Chinese people. He asked me to do something about it.

So I wrote to him about this. He said that he could not find any pictures of the Great Leap Forward, therefore he had to use what he could find. There goes his academic honesty! I asked him to share his evidence. He said that he can not reveal that evidence because he had a confidential agreement with the source. I said that you could not do that. He said if I came to his office in Hongkong, he would let me look at it. I could not go to Hong Kong, so I asked a friend to see him.

It turned out that the evidence he had was Chairman Mao's speech about the national investment projects. Chairman Mao said that he wanted to cut the national investment projects by half. so that the remaining half would get enough money to complete in time. He either did not understand the Chinese language or he was maliciously misleading the reader. He got two and half million dollars from Jiang Jingguo Foundation in Taiwan for his book."

Reader's avatar

That Genetics of Political Belief book is something else! 😂😂😂

4 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?