Discussion about this post

User's avatar
FlügelderFreiheit's avatar

There is ignorance luck in chess. You are not equally well prepared for every opening your opponent could play and can't know for sure which it will be. Sometimes your preparation lasts till the game is over, sometimes you are on your own after a couple of moves.

Expand full comment
BH's avatar

It definitely depends on the skill level of the players playing the game in question. For example, Super Smash Bros is probably way more skill based than Chess at lower levels. Low level players in Chess tend not to plan ahead a great deal of moves and so opportunities sort of just open up out of the aether. But then when you get to upper level chess you have a much deeper awareness of everything on the board and so things happen less and less by serendipity.

Meanwhile with Smash (no items, tournament legal stage) assuming the players aren’t using some sort of gimmick, the experience is already pretty intuitive and lucky chances already require some deal of skill to take advantage of. But as you move up players gain more mastery of their characters, which means that character matchups matter more and more. One thing I experienced playing Smash bros. is that the tier list makes no sense when you’re bad at the game, but you understand it more and more as you get better. Obviously this means that between two random players, their raw skill matters less.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts