Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Watts's avatar

> The picking rates are affected by players’ choice based on their guesses about which relic gives the best winning chances, so it is not a clean causal estimate. However, the offers are random, so they allow us to get around this.

The offers are random? Did they fix their nonrandomness bug?

Leaf's avatar
Oct 7Edited

As a dedicated, but mediocre at best, player of StS, I think your suggestion that picking better relics in shops significantly contributes to good players’ win rates is off base. Your sample only includes players on A10, which already excludes the worst players. Everyone in your sample must already have some idea of the best cards or they wouldn’t even be at A10, because picking good cards is essential to winning even on lower ascensions. By contrast, buying good relics in the shop is less important just because it happens much less often. But the best players are able to stack up even those small contributions to winning that mediocre players like me miss. I think the most important thing the best players do is understand which cards to take in the context of the run, which can’t be picked up by this analysis.

Edit: on re-reading I see that you actually include all ascensions, but people have to upload their runs to your site to be included. I suspect this even more strongly biases your data towards only good players. This can still be useful advice for players who are already good and want to become even better, but I don’t think it says much about a typical player.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?