> The picking rates are affected by players’ choice based on their guesses about which relic gives the best winning chances, so it is not a clean causal estimate. However, the offers are random, so they allow us to get around this.
The offers are random? Did they fix their nonrandomness bug?
As a dedicated, but mediocre at best, player of StS, I think your suggestion that picking better relics in shops significantly contributes to good players’ win rates is off base. Your sample only includes players on A10, which already excludes the worst players. Everyone in your sample must already have some idea of the best cards or they wouldn’t even be at A10, because picking good cards is essential to winning even on lower ascensions. By contrast, buying good relics in the shop is less important just because it happens much less often. But the best players are able to stack up even those small contributions to winning that mediocre players like me miss. I think the most important thing the best players do is understand which cards to take in the context of the run, which can’t be picked up by this analysis.
Edit: on re-reading I see that you actually include all ascensions, but people have to upload their runs to your site to be included. I suspect this even more strongly biases your data towards only good players. This can still be useful advice for players who are already good and want to become even better, but I don’t think it says much about a typical player.
The conditional analysis can in principle find the card combinations. I looked into this in more detail using the theory/winning-decks based priors. It just shows you what you would expect. If you already have sly cards, then being offered discard cards predicts winning. If you already have Sleight of Flesh, being offered condition cards predicts winning. And so on.
I don't know what the selection bias is exactly. Only the developers can know I think. It doesn't seem to matter that much, given that we can see the effects of player skill on choices being made. Better players make choices more in line with what the causal analyses find is best.
This is a very good game that is economical as to cost. I have made it to the top of the Spire with Defect, Silent and Necrobinder. I have actually made it to the top twice with Silent. As you get to the top with a character, you can make the setting more difficult. The game uses a RNG as to what is offered as rewards so each run is going to be very different. Relics are important but so are cards. Certain cards are game changers. Silent has a card that once you play it whenever you draw cards, you deal 2 damage to the enemy. When you combine that with poison and upgraded shivs, you will be causing a lot of damage.
It's the easiest one IMO, also in STS1. There are many who haven't made it (yet). Like this guy, https://sts2.fun/player/solar-automaton, 156 tries at Defect A10, 0 wins.
The favorite card stat counts the number of times at least one copy of the card appeared, or the total number of copies of the card appearing in the deck?
If it is the former, we have a psychopathic uproar enjoyer here. (147 out of 186, ignoring the instances where he might have gotten it in other characters)
> The picking rates are affected by players’ choice based on their guesses about which relic gives the best winning chances, so it is not a clean causal estimate. However, the offers are random, so they allow us to get around this.
The offers are random? Did they fix their nonrandomness bug?
Yes they fixed it a while ago. But some of the options come from specific pools.
As a dedicated, but mediocre at best, player of StS, I think your suggestion that picking better relics in shops significantly contributes to good players’ win rates is off base. Your sample only includes players on A10, which already excludes the worst players. Everyone in your sample must already have some idea of the best cards or they wouldn’t even be at A10, because picking good cards is essential to winning even on lower ascensions. By contrast, buying good relics in the shop is less important just because it happens much less often. But the best players are able to stack up even those small contributions to winning that mediocre players like me miss. I think the most important thing the best players do is understand which cards to take in the context of the run, which can’t be picked up by this analysis.
Edit: on re-reading I see that you actually include all ascensions, but people have to upload their runs to your site to be included. I suspect this even more strongly biases your data towards only good players. This can still be useful advice for players who are already good and want to become even better, but I don’t think it says much about a typical player.
"Your sample only includes players on A10"
Not true. I don't know why you think that.
The conditional analysis can in principle find the card combinations. I looked into this in more detail using the theory/winning-decks based priors. It just shows you what you would expect. If you already have sly cards, then being offered discard cards predicts winning. If you already have Sleight of Flesh, being offered condition cards predicts winning. And so on.
I don't know what the selection bias is exactly. Only the developers can know I think. It doesn't seem to matter that much, given that we can see the effects of player skill on choices being made. Better players make choices more in line with what the causal analyses find is best.
Would you mind making a response to this article?
https://quantitativehistory.substack.com/p/socioeconomic-factors?r=31ft4d&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=post%20viewer
It's just sociologist's fallacy in long form.
What would you say to the claim that the B/W crime rate is closing due to environmental reasons, i see this get brought up a lot.
I have zero interest in this.
This is a very good game that is economical as to cost. I have made it to the top of the Spire with Defect, Silent and Necrobinder. I have actually made it to the top twice with Silent. As you get to the top with a character, you can make the setting more difficult. The game uses a RNG as to what is offered as rewards so each run is going to be very different. Relics are important but so are cards. Certain cards are game changers. Silent has a card that once you play it whenever you draw cards, you deal 2 damage to the enemy. When you combine that with poison and upgraded shivs, you will be causing a lot of damage.
I see slay the spire 2 and I click.
That's cause I'm addicted.
Please help (me beat silent ascension 10).
It's the easiest one IMO, also in STS1. There are many who haven't made it (yet). Like this guy, https://sts2.fun/player/solar-automaton, 156 tries at Defect A10, 0 wins.
The favorite card stat counts the number of times at least one copy of the card appeared, or the total number of copies of the card appearing in the deck?
If it is the former, we have a psychopathic uproar enjoyer here. (147 out of 186, ignoring the instances where he might have gotten it in other characters)