8 Comments
User's avatar
Realist's avatar

Excellent analysis and conclusion.

"Now no one can credibly claim that origin country metrics do not predict migrant outcomes consistently."

You can see this playing out in the UK and Western Europe right now.

RenOS's avatar

Amazing, thanks very much. If I may ask, what AI tools do you use? Chatgpt and Claude often are squeamish and reluctant to do analysis that go against contemporary taboos, though I usually get them to do it anyway. Grok, at least back when I tried it, wasn't, but unfortunately seemed generally more careless and less competent.

Emil O. W. Kirkegaard's avatar

Claude Opus 5.5 currently. Never complains about these things.

Jared's avatar

What kind of complaints do other models give

Bradley's avatar

Great work. Hope the Times and the Guardian run this on page one, with editorials in support.

One can dream!

Mike Conrad's avatar

Thanks as always for your comprehensive and disciplined analysis, presented so clearly that even a layman such as myself can understand it!

Dave's avatar

I asked Google AI two questions. Here’s its response:

“Out of a population of 50 million with an average IQ of 85 how many would be above 100?

About 8 million people out of a 50 million population would have an IQ above 100.

The Mathematical Breakdown

IQ scores follow a normal distribution (bell curve) with a standard standard deviation (\(\sigma \)) of 15 points. Here is how the calculation works:

Calculate the Z-Score: The threshold score of 100 is exactly 1 standard deviation above the given population average of 85 (\(100 - 85 = 15\)).

Find the Percentage: In a standard normal distribution, exactly 15.87% of a population scores higher than 1 standard deviation above the mean.

Apply to the Population: 15.8655% of 50,000,000 yields 7,932,763 people.

How many of that 50 million would have an IQ at or above 130?

Approximately 67,495 people out of the 50 million population would have an IQ above 130.

The Mathematical Breakdown

Calculate the Z-Score: An IQ of 130 is exactly 3 standard deviations above the population average of 85 (\(130 - 85 = 45\), and \(45 / 15 = 3\)).

Find the Percentage: In a standard normal distribution, only 0.135% of a population scores higher than 3 standard deviations above the mean.

Apply to the Population: 0.00135% of 50,000,000 yields exactly 67,495 people.”

bakter's avatar

It's , the IQ disteibution, depend on the ethnicity, depend on the nation. In Finnland or in northern, Scandinav countries, the IQ distribution is relatively even, uniform, while f.e. in Israel, the distribution much more exponential, the curve is more steep. Geniuses "like to come" from societies where the average IQ is high, but the IQ distribution is not that balanced.